A wave of defaults by coffee traders and warehouses receiving consigned coffee in Đắk Lắk has erupted in rapid succession, leaving thousands of farmers reeling. Tonnes of their stored coffee have vanished with no clear trace.
Thousands of Farmers Left Empty-Handed
In Buôn Hồ town and the districts of Krông Búk and Krông Năng, panic has gripped farmers after coffee dealer Hà Thị Vui, of 647 Hùng Vương Street, Thiện An Ward, publicly declared insolvency.
-
Đỗ Thị Kim Phương (An Lạc Ward) lamented: “After harvest we stored all 8 tons of coffee beans with Ms. Vui, waiting for a higher price. When we went to settle, she said she had lost money and couldn’t pay. Without that coffee, I don’t know how to cover debts for fertilizer, fuel and bank loans now due.”
-
Lâm Thị Hoa (Thiện An Ward) faces losing her home: she mortgaged it to the bank while keeping 3 tons of coffee with Vui. “Now the bank is about to auction my house and she turns her back,” Hoa said.
Authorities report Vui and her husband Nguyễn Đại Thắng owe 91 tons of coffee beans and 8 billion VND in cash to 17 people, with no means to repay. The largest single loss belongs to Nguyễn Thị Cường of Pơng Drang commune, Krông Búk district—50 tons of coffee, worth about 2 billion VND.
Elsewhere in Buôn Hồ, many other companies and agents—Chung Đào Co. Ltd., Tân Trường Nguyên Coffee, and agents Phương Thành, Lan Lương, Nguyễn Thị Lan, Phạm Thị Loan, among others—have also collapsed, collectively owing hundreds of billions of VND to over 600 victims.
In Krông Năng district, 96 households in Ea Hồ, Ea Tóh, Phú Lộc communes and Krông Năng town recently won a lawsuit against Hiệp Gái coffee agency—owned by Trương Minh Hiệp and Trần Thị Gái—which had taken nearly 200 tons of consigned coffee and then declared default.
Nguyễn Thanh Minh of Ea Tóh said: “I stored 2.5 tons of coffee worth 100 million VND, but the civil enforcement agency could recover only 30,000 VND for me. I regret even bothering to sue.”
Deputy head of Krông Năng’s civil enforcement office Nguyễn Bá Tình added wryly: “Those 96 households’ claims total 7.561 billion VND, but the couple’s remaining assets cover only 0.03% of the debt. Each victim will get merely 0.03% of what they are owed.”
Legal Dilemmas and Calls for Criminal Charges
After numerous complaints, Vui herself filed a “petition for help,” claiming that all her land-title deeds were already held by another creditor, preventing repayment.
Initially, Thiện An ward police reported on 28 September 2011 that the case showed “no criminal signs” and was a civil dispute. Victims were advised to sue in court.
However, Judge Nguyễn Văn Nhàng, Chief Justice of Buôn Hồ People’s Court, said: “Our review shows criminal signs. Vui knew she had already suffered losses yet continued to borrow and accept consigned coffee. We will recommend prosecution.”
Similarly, Judge Trần Ngọc Anh of Krông Năng People’s Court noted that civil suits are futile: “Before declaring default, these operators usually transfer their assets. Even if farmers win in court there’s nothing to enforce. We need criminal prosecutions to deter those who exploit defaults to seize farmers’ property.”
According to the Đắk Lắk Provincial People’s Committee, 43 coffee businesses, agents and traders have defaulted, with total losses of roughly 300 billion VND in cash, 3,000 tons of coffee beans and 22 tons of pepper. These defaults have shaken rural livelihoods and threatened public order across the province.